The final vote on the antisemitism bill in the Chamber of Deputies in Rome. (Ph Roberto Monaldo / LaPresse)

The final vote on the antisemitism bill in the Chamber of Deputies in Rome. (Ph Roberto Monaldo / LaPresse) (© LaPresse)

Politics

Italy Passes Antisemitism Law Amid Bitter Debate and Opposition Split

The center-right, joined by the centrist parties Azione and Italia Viva, backed the measure. The Democratic Party, the Five Star Movement and the Greens and Left Alliance voted against it, while five Democratic lawmakers abstained.

Niccolò Carratelli

ROME — Liliana Segre had urged lawmakers to address antisemitism in a spirit of unity and pass the legislation unanimously. It could hardly have gone more differently.

The House of Representatives gave final approval to the bill after a bitter debate marked by heated exchanges and moments of high tension. The vote exposed deep divisions across Parliament — and, as expected, within the center-left opposition.

All parties in Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni’s governing coalition voted in favor, joined by the centrist parties Azione and Italia Viva. The Five Star Movement, the Greens and Left Alliance, the Democratic Party — following the line set by party leader Elly Schlein — and Futuro Nazionale voted against. But not all Democratic lawmakers followed the party leadership: five members of the party’s House delegation — Lorenzo Guerini, Piero Fassino, Lia Quartapelle, Virginio Merola and Nicola Carè — abstained rather than vote against the bill. Riccardo Magi, leader of the More Europe party, did not take part in the vote.

The divisions had already surfaced during the bill’s passage through the Senate last March, when six Democratic senators broke with the party’s abstention line and voted in favor. The party later shifted to outright opposition after the governing majority refused to amend the text to explicitly rule out the possibility that the new provisions could restrict criticism of the Israeli government’s actions.

That was the central concern raised in the House by lawmakers from the three main opposition parties, who sought to give political voice to the broad pro-Palestinian movement, whose dozens of organizations had mobilized against the legislation.

At issue is the bill’s adoption of the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance’s (IHRA) working definition of antisemitism and its accompanying examples. One of the most frequently cited examples identifies as antisemitic the comparison of the policies of Israel’s current government to those of the Nazi regime.

The Democratic Party, the Five Star Movement and the Greens and Left Alliance saw all their proposed amendments rejected. The result, Nicola Fratoianni argued, showed how the right was wielding the legislation as “a political bludgeon.” The leader of the Italian Left party warned that it could become “a baton in the hands of those who want to repress every form of dissent against the policies of the Israeli government.”

“The fight against antisemitism must not be confused with censorship,” said Chiara Braga, the Democratic Party’s House leader.

Livia Ottolenghi, President of the Union of Italian Jewish Communities, took the opposite view, describing the legislation as “a concrete response that safeguards freedom of expression and strengthens the democratic antibodies of Italian civil society.”

The right, meanwhile, repeatedly described the measure as “a law befitting a civilized country.” Some lawmakers also pointed out that the IHRA definition had been approved by the European Parliament with Schlein’s support and subsequently adopted in Italy by the second government led by Giuseppe Conte.

The debate reached its most heated points twice.

The first came when Mauro Malaguti, a lawmaker from the far-right Brothers of Italy party, challenged what he called the “narrative of genocide in Gaza.” He cited figures published by the Gaza Health Ministry, which is controlled by Hamas, arguing that the balance between births and deaths was positive.

“The number of births exceeds the number of deaths by 1.2 percent — one of the highest rates in the world: 6,000 births every month,” Malaguti said.

His remarks triggered an angry response from lawmakers in the Greens and Left Alliance, the Five Star Movement and the Democratic Party. Tensions escalated further after Luigi Marattin, leader of the Liberal Democratic Party, backed Malaguti’s argument. Among the most incensed was Democratic lawmaker Enzo Amendola, who had to be physically restrained as he tried to approach Marattin.

The second confrontation erupted during the vote on the final motion, which concerned naming streets and squares after figures from Italy’s Fascist era.

Rossano Sasso, a lawmaker from Futuro Nazionale, brought up the assassination of philosopher Giovanni Gentile, saying he had been killed by “cowardly Communist barbarians.” Alessandro Amorese, of Brothers of Italy, went further: “They killed an elderly man outside his home because he was a moderate.”

The remarks prompted an angry response from Democratic lawmaker Gianni Cuperlo. “We have just heard words that bring shame on Parliament,” he said, before being drowned out by shouts from the right.

Cuperlo then lost his temper: “Shut up, fascists!”

The chamber erupted. Giorgio Mulè, the deputy speaker presiding over the session, called Cuperlo to order, but the lawmaker stood his ground.

“I called them fascists, and I will always do so to anyone in this chamber who calls the partisans cowards and murderers,” he said.