

undefined
Telmo Pievani: “Our Weakness Is What Makes Us Evolve”
The philosopher of science warns against blind faith in technology and the belief that science can solve every crisis. “We evolved by protecting the vulnerable, not by attacking our enemies.”
It takes very little to bring our world — and, with it, ourselves — crashing down. A small, invisible, untraceable adversary can throw entire societies into disarray, just as we are once again trying to turn them into impenetrable fortresses: hostile, self-sufficient strongholds, under the dangerous illusion that threats come only from outside and can never emerge from within.
That is what happened with Covid, and it is happening again with hybrid warfare. The siege comes from within; the collapse is the consequence of our excesses, our negligence and our illusions. The systems we have built in the name of connection, control, security, convenience and speed suddenly reveal themselves to be fragile — more fallible, in fact, than the human beings they were supposed to help make less fallible.

Telmo Pievani, philosopher of science and evolutionary biologist.
“We have built technologies that operate through a single channel, making ourselves dependent on one technological approach and exposing ourselves to an obvious vulnerability. If we rely on just three or four Big Tech companies, the moment they come under attack or decide to pull the plug, we have no alternatives and are immediately in serious trouble. It is a typically human strategic mistake, because we lack foresight. We behave as though new technologies were inevitable and unsinkable, forgetting that they are inherently vulnerable,” Telmo Pievani tells La Stampa.
A philosopher of science and evolutionary biologist who teaches at the University of Milan, Pievani has long challenged the myth that invincibility and strength are the driving forces of survival and progress.
Professor, does this inherent weakness of new technologies originate in human nature?
“For a very long time, we have been building artifacts — and, at this stage, especially algorithms — to help us with ordinary and extraordinary tasks. But these tools eventually become constraints, in the sense that they turn into the environment in which we have to live. That is more or less how the evolutionary game works: We change the world through technology, and then we have to adapt to a world filled with technology. Our brains are now being challenged to adapt to AI.
“The fragility comes from errors of perspective: We overestimate ourselves and the tools we create. That is human nature.”
Is it particularly a Western problem?
“That’s an important distinction. Other cultures have a different sensibility. I admire Indigenous peoples who speak of ‘constructive paranoia.’ They remember a negative event that occurred in a particular place — a tree falling and killing someone, for example, or a flood — and decide never to do anything there again. It may seem irrational, even animistic, but it is actually wise and respectful of an obvious fact: Nature is far greater than we are.
“Last week, Italy’s environmental protection agency, ISPRA, published a report on land consumption showing a 22 percent increase between 2024 and 2025. That is madness, because it means we are continuing to seal the ground with concrete and asphalt. Even more absurdly, we are doing it in flood-prone areas vulnerable to landslides.”
Is this absurdity fueled by the “absolutism of desire” that Vito Mancuso discussed in this newspaper?
“Yes, absolutely. Some have described contemporary capitalism as ‘dopaminergic’ — designed to trigger bursts of pleasure by satisfying desires that, to keep working and overcome our growing tolerance, must become ever greater.
“But we cannot place all the blame on individuals. They are responding to a system designed to keep them perpetually dissatisfied and dependent. The latest technologies, from social media onward, are engineered to generate those dopamine surges.”
Could AI offer a way out of social media's grip?
“Not if we continue using AI controlled by large private corporations. The more we use it, the more we improve it — for free — while generating enormous profits for its owners. Europe arrived late, but it has finally understood what is needed: a European AI system that is public and transparent.
“The first data centers, however, will not be ready until 2027. Even if everyone agrees, we will only be able to use them in 2028. A great deal can change in two years.”
The philosopher Maurizio Ferraris has often argued that big data is a humanistic treasure.
“That is absolutely true. His argument concerns the evolution of our ability to preserve humanity’s collective memory. But there is a complementary aspect: Sometimes we need to understand that forgetting is perfectly fine, too.
“The future of AI will be personal companions: customized systems tailored to each of us that will document everything and remember it all — the emails we send, our reactions, our meetings, even bodily analyses of our emotions. Some transhumanists say we will achieve digital immortality. To me, that is a delusional prospect.”
Is there such a thing as good digital technology and bad digital technology?
“One of the founding fathers of cybernetics — the grandmother of AI — said that a new technology is good, or is being used properly, when it makes us freer. That is no longer happening, but we can make sure it starts happening again.”
Are digital life and real life separate?
“The digital world is not virtual. AI is flesh and blood; it is life. Data centers consume land: There is a material dimension to these technologies that we often forget. They are not ethereal.”
Does hybrid warfare remind you of Covid?
“Very much so. Now, as then, we are frustrated by how opaque our adversary is. Indeed, ever since hackers first emerged, they have ended up being recruited by the very systems they once targeted, because those systems know no other way to fight them.
“The pandemic had been predicted in considerable detail, and we chose to ignore those warnings. It had also long been clear that neglecting cybersecurity would put us at risk. Covid was not simply a viral pandemic emergency. The problem was not the virus itself, but the ecological conditions we had created — conditions that make pandemics more likely.
“Last year, Nature published a study that was largely ignored, showing that the risk of a pandemic more dangerous than Covid is far higher than it was in 2019. This is precisely the kind of news that is routinely pushed out of public debate, when the only rational thing to do is talk about it.”
Isn't it paradoxical that we are irrational in the age of technology?
“No. It happens precisely because we delegate rationality to technology. The scientific community has been alerted to this risk, and researchers are working to ensure that, if another virus emerges, a vaccine can be developed in 100 days rather than nine months.
“Of course, that is important and extraordinary. But it also reveals a way of turning to science that I fundamentally reject: a utilitarian approach based on the illusion that we will always be saved by some genius. That is not how it works.
“Science does not perform miracles. It can work alongside a humanity willing to change harmful and senseless ways of life.”
Could it simply be that we are destroying ourselves because it is in our nature?
“There are many signs that humanity may be heading toward collapse. But we are a young species, and if we went extinct now, it would mean we were not particularly intelligent. Let’s just say that, for the time being, we still have to earn the right to call ourselves sapiens.
“What we already know is that we are an ambivalent and destructive species: We have caused the extinction of hundreds of other species.”
Give me some good news.
“We also have artistic abilities, the capacity to explore what is possible, and the ability to care for others, especially the most vulnerable. I disagree with those who say history is driven solely by power struggles and that what we need is realpolitik. That is an extremely dangerous argument. Historians tell us that such ideas always emerge before major wars and disasters.
“History has also been shaped by imagination, ideas and trust. Nelson Mandela began imagining the end of apartheid while he was in prison, where he spent 27 years.”
Who are the strong?
“The losers. Nature documentaries always show us predators attacking and killing their prey. But those of us who study evolution know that in 95 percent of cases, the antelope does not even see the predator. And by the end of the encounter, the predator is exhausted, perched in a tree.
“Male predators lead a hellish existence: They live far shorter lives than other males and spend all their time with sky-high testosterone and stress-hormone levels.
“The same applies to human beings. We became the true masters of the world when we learned to protect the most vulnerable members of our group. We evolved by working together to defend ourselves against predators, not by attacking them.”









