The perfect formula: hot dogs, fried potatoes, peppers, and onions served in the characteristic half-moon of pizza bread

The perfect formula: hot dogs, fried potatoes, peppers, and onions served in the characteristic half-moon of pizza bread

Food & Beverage

Once Upon a Time in Newark: Mary's Italian Hot Dog

The story behind the rise of a New Jersey culinary icon

Manuela Jael Procaccia

Newark, 1932. In Mary Racioppi's kitchen on Fourth Street, the oil sizzles, potatoes turn golden, peppers and onions fry. She tucks two hot dogs into a hollowed-out round loaf of pizza bread. "It's like a big bagel or fat pita," says her great-grandson Tommy Racioppi. A New Jersey culinary icon is born: the Italian Hot Dog.

It is the Great Depression. Nothing goes to waste. Mary first makes the sandwich for her husband James and his friends as they play poker. "After a while, people started coming just to eat," her grandson Jimmy later recalled. "Forget the card game!" What began as a family meal spills out of the kitchen and turns into a family lifeline. On August 1, 1932, Mary and James open the first Jimmy Buff's at 202 14th Avenue, named for James's poker-table nickname, "Buff."

The formula is simple and perfect: two hot dogs, deep-fried potatoes, sweet peppers and onions, all piled into dense, fresh pizza bread that soaks up the grease without falling apart. It is hearty, portable and unmistakably Italian-American, exactly the kind of food that could feed a working neighborhood during hard times.

The exterior of the historic Jimmy Buff's in Newark, where Mary's intuition became an institution.

Ninety years later the original Newark location is gone, but the memories remain. In the Facebook group Jersey Hot Dog Joints, people still remember working there after school in the 1950s, "peeling potatoes and onions and crying a lot." Others remember the lines: "We couldn't park close because of the line to get to it! You could smell the peppers and onions blocks away!" Another remembers skipping school for Jimmy Buff's; the grease stains on his shirt always gave him away to his mother. The tradition lives on in West Orange, where Tommy Racioppi, Mary's great-grandson, carries on what she and James began. Four generations on, the lines still form, and Mary still has her devotees. One calls her the "Saint of Hot Dogs" and offers a blessing: "May she live on in potatoes, peppers and onions."