In the TV series All’s Fair, engagement and rejection go hand in hand

In the TV series All’s Fair, engagement and rejection go hand in hand

Shows

All’s Fair and Hate-Watching: The Success of Shows We Love to Loathe

Scathing reviews and a renewal in just twenty days: All’s Fair returns for a second season, revealing the power of attention, even when it stems from disapproval

Sara Matteucci

All’s Fair returns on November 4 for its second season on Hulu in the United States and Disney+ in Italy: eight episodes, with the first three available at launch. Ryan Murphy’s legal drama returns to the divide that defined its debut: scathing reviews, millions of views, and a swift renewal.

Watching a show, anticipating its twists, discussing it with friends, and finding it exasperating all the while: this is the contradiction at the heart of hate-watching. The term combines “hate” and “watching” to describe a viewing experience that draws pleasure from irritation, criticism, or the opportunity to ridicule a show’s flaws. Engagement and rejection can sustain each other: we return for the next episode partly to have something to object to.

All’s Fair offers a case study in this ambivalence. When its first season premiered in November 2025, it drew 3.2 million global views in its first three days, according to internal figures reported by TheWrap, making it the biggest debut for a Hulu scripted original series in three years. On November 24, just twenty days after its launch, the renewal was announced. Meanwhile, The Guardian’s Lucy Mangan had awarded it zero stars. On Rotten Tomatoes, the first season currently holds a 6% approval rating from critics across 34 reviews, compared with a 65% audience score.

The reasons we keep watching can therefore be varied, even contradictory. A 2025 study published in First Monday, conducted by T. Phillip Madison and colleagues, explored the gratifications associated with hate-watching through interviews with 23 college students. The motivations that emerged included moral superiority, affirmation of existing beliefs, guilty pleasure, and social bonding.

The term “hate-watching” was already circulating in the second half of the 2000s and gained prominence in 2012, when Emily Nussbaum published “Hate-Watching ‘Smash’” in The New Yorker, examining her own compulsion to follow a show that infuriated her. Online conversation offered a second audience, turning private irritation into a shared experience. The pleasure continued beyond the episode, in exchanges with others who had found the same scene unbearable.

Turning flaws into attractions has famous precedents. The Room, the 2003 film written and directed by Tommy Wiseau, who also starred in it, turned its terrible reputation into a cult following, making its creator famous in the process. This is the neighboring territory of “so bad it’s good,” where mockery and affection become intertwined. It also offers a possible lens through which to view All’s Fair, which has prompted debate about the boundary between a simply bad show and a potential trash-TV cult classic.

Here, however, celebrity appeal was already a source of curiosity. At the center of the project is Kim Kardashian, its star and an executive producer, alongside acclaimed performers including Glenn Close, Sarah Paulson, and Niecy Nash-Betts, as well as Naomi Watts and Teyana Taylor. Before the plot even enters the picture, the leading women promise an event. Murphy, the creator of Nip/Tuck and American Horror Story, brings together acting prestige and reality TV celebrity. For Kardashian, following American Horror Story: Delicate, this is her first leading role in a scripted series. With roughly 344 million Instagram followers, she also brings a potential audience whose interest predates any verdict on her performance.

Set in Los Angeles, the series follows a group of female attorneys who leave a male-dominated firm to establish their own women-led practice specializing in divorce. Amid multimillion-dollar cases, betrayals, and revenge, their clients’ stories intertwine with the protagonists’ personal crises, exploring financial independence, solidarity among women, and the possibility of starting over.

It was precisely the translation of these ambitions into spectacle that fueled some of the first season’s harshest criticism. In Variety, Alison Herman took issue with a feminism built on slogans and ostentation, comparing its portrayal of work to Selling Sunset, the reality show about luxury real estate agents in Los Angeles. In Judy Berman’s review for Time, that glossy surface made watching the show feel like leafing through a high-end women’s magazine, moving between fashion spreads and punchy pull quotes.

Ahead of the new season, Kardashian revisited the scathing reviews in an interview with Mamamia’s The Spill podcast, published on November 2. “And I’m sorry that I ruined their careers,” she joked, recalling her fear of letting her co-stars down and the reassurance she received from Sarah Paulson. In the promotional narrative surrounding the show’s return, even the critical drubbing becomes an anecdote to share.

From the television screen to vertical video on social media, hate-watching extends beyond the episode: the pleasure of criticism generates new content, which in turn attracts attention. The work is almost cannibalized: scenes and lines are isolated, commented on, and reassembled into parodies and reaction videos, reaching even people who have never watched the show.

How much of this second life is already envisioned during production? Do viewers take the story apart on their own initiative, or do the scenes offer material already primed to circulate independently? A review in The Atlantic offers a way to explore this question, interpreting the editing in All’s Fair as an attempt to reproduce the experience of a social media feed: private jets, jewelry, lavish lunches, Kardashian’s instantly recognizable face. A succession of visual hooks that seems to anticipate the passage from episode to fragment.

Whether this reflects a deliberate choice or a convergence of visual languages, the show lends itself to a conversation that extends its life. Alongside professional criticism comes the vox populi of social media, driven by desire, derision, and the pleasure of taking part. In this exchange, even panning a show can become a way to stay involved while distancing ourselves from something that, after all, entertains us.

Allowing ourselves to watch something to unwind, laugh at it, and discuss it also means freeing our viewing choices from the imperative of cultural prestige. A pleasure that does not require us to keep defending our taste.

After a debut marked by a dismal critical reception and strong audience interest, it remains to be seen whether the new season will earn another renewal, perhaps with help from those already preparing to loathe it. Because in hate-watching, even disapproval can fuel anticipation.