Indianapolis Fruit Venders, Italian Boys, Aug. 1908.

Indianapolis Fruit Venders, Italian Boys, Aug. 1908.

Society

Before the Interstates, Indy Had a Little Italy

Long before I-65 cut through it, a pocket southeast of downtown Indianapolis was almost entirely Italian

Loredana "Lola" Messa

Ask most people about Indiana's immigrant history and they will mention German breweries or Irish railroad crews. Almost nobody pictures Sicily. Yet by 1910, roughly ninety percent of the residents living a mile southeast of Monument Circle were Italian immigrants.

Today, the 49-acre pocket bounded by South East Street, Virginia Avenue, and Interstates 65 and 70 carries a mouthful of a name: the Holy Rosary-Danish Church Historic District. The hyphen tells the story of real estate turnover. Germans and Irish settled the blocks after the land was platted in 1854, followed by a wave of Danish families who built Trinity Danish Evangelical Lutheran Church in 1872. As the Danes moved on, southern Italians, mostly from Sicily, bought up the modest carpenter-builder cottages.

Many of those Sicilian arrivals went straight into the produce business. Operating pushcarts, wholesale stalls, and corner fruit stands near the city market, families turned crate-hauling into steady paychecks. The neighborhood ran on tight-knit routines: kids walked to Horace Mann Public School No. 13, neighbors traded backyard garden harvests over low fences, and everyone pooled spare change for a parish of their own.

In 1909, Father Marino Priori arrived to establish Our Lady of the Most Holy Rosary. Money was tight enough that parishioners worshipped in the basement for years while the limestone walls rose overhead, modeled after Rome's Church of San Giorgio in Velabro. The finished church was finally dedicated in 1925.

Postwar highway construction and Eli Lilly's campus expansion eventually sliced through the old blocks, shrinking the resident population. Still, the neighborhood's annual Italian Street Festival, started during the Depression in 1934 to keep the church lights on, draws crowds back to Stevens Street every June.