

Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg (© ANSA)
Meta Fined €805 Million in Italy Over Facebook Access to Users’ Photos and Videos
Italy’s privacy watchdog says the tech giant accessed the photo galleries of 20 million users without obtaining specific consent. Meta strongly disputes the ruling and plans to appeal.
Italy's data protection authority has fined Meta €805 million ($887 million), accusing the company of accessing the personal data of 20 million Italian users through its Facebook app for Android devices. The ruling concerns unauthorized access to photos, videos and metadata stored on users' mobile phones. The watchdog says Meta failed to obtain specific consent before accessing users' personal media libraries.
The decision sets strict regulatory boundaries for technology platforms operating in Europe, reaffirming a fundamental principle under the ePrivacy Directive: “A smartphone is protected as part of an individual's private sphere.”
Meta strongly disagrees with the ruling and says it will appeal.
The fine amounts to 0.47% of the California-based company's global revenue. The investigation began in July 2025 following a formal complaint filed by the Bolzano Consumer Protection Center. It focused on a feature called “Get suggestions from your camera roll while browsing Facebook.” Available since 2023, the feature suggests photos and videos stored on a user's phone as potential content to share on the social network.
The technical investigation found that Meta's handling of access permissions lacked transparency. The app requested permission to access media files through a single authorization covering the entire application, even though its various features served different purposes and had different operational requirements.
The permission request was preceded by a generic notification asking users to “enable additional features.” The wording did not make clear that granting access would also activate photo and video suggestions drawn from the phone's gallery.
The feature under investigation was enabled by default on mobile devices. As a result, the authorization allowed the software to access the entire photo library on an ongoing basis. Neither users nor the regulator had any way to verify which information was retrieved or used by Meta's servers.
The Italian watchdog found that Meta had violated Article 122 of Italy's Privacy Code, which implements the European ePrivacy Directive into national law. The provision requires users' freely given consent before any information stored on a personal device can be accessed.
That requirement applies regardless of whether the data is actually transmitted outside the device or whether the user suffers any financial harm.
During the proceedings, Meta's lawyers challenged the Italian authority's jurisdiction, arguing that the case should be transferred to Ireland's data protection regulator, since the company's European Headquarters is based there. The Italian watchdog rejected the request, citing the applicable legal framework. The ePrivacy rules are not subject to the EU's one-stop-shop mechanism, confirming the Italian authority's jurisdiction over the case.
The investigation focused exclusively on access to users' photos and videos. It did not examine whether the content might have been used to train artificial intelligence models. Meta denied engaging in such practices during the hearings. The watchdog said it may investigate separately a new feature launched in 2026 that processes gallery content using external cloud infrastructure.
The ruling gives Meta 60 days to implement structural changes. The company must obtain consent through a separate request specifically covering the feature. On-screen notices must clearly explain the service's purpose, the implications of granting access to the phone's media library and how users can disable the feature.
Meta must also ensure that the feature is turned off by default for all users, including those who may have previously granted permission. If the company fails to comply by the deadline, the feature will be blocked for users who have not provided valid consent.
Meta, for its part, says it “strongly disagrees” with the decision, arguing that “users must grant permission on their device before the feature can operate and can change that permission at any time in their settings.”
The company's appeal is expected to be the next step.









